1969
George Barr (OK)
Ford Frick (NY)
Col. Dominic George (CA)

1970
Vern Hernlund (IL)
Mickey Lolich (MI)

1971
Stan Gray (CA)
Ed Hunt (CT)
Oscar Twillman (MO)

1972
Jack Gilliam (VA)
Carl Lundquist (NY)
Frank Stapleton (OR)

1973
Paul Carey (NY)
Jan Hartog (The Netherlands)
Samuel Welch (NJ)

1974
Mrs. F. Warren Green (NY)
J. Russell Lacy (NJ)
Lawrence P. Moser (MI)
Dr. William G. Williams (CT)

1975
Manueal Azevedo (CA)
Ray Bell (NJ)
Joseph Cookson (PA)
John (Sharkey) Laureno (CT)
Del Schrader (CA)
George Wyse (WA)

1976
William Hollifield (NC)
Wilf Sadler (BC)

1977
L.O. Cutler (NC)
Russ Harper (AL)
Paul Sayevich (NY)

1978
Pete Romano (WV)

1979
Tom Dowd (MA)
Francis Fogle (OH)
Oscar Luzzi (NY)

1980
Alfred G. Stanton (NC)

1981
Ed Wiest (CA)

1982
William Crowley (MA)
Nicholas Salvage (NY)
Ralph Sellers (LA)

1983
J. Jervey Gantt (FL)
Bob Harmon (TX)

1984
Harry Lewin (WV)

1985
Douglas W. Bryden (WY)
Clifford S. Conner (NC)
Charles W. Cooper (IN)
Stan Filmer (CT)
Duane "Buck" Ward (WY)

1986
William H. Clifton (NC)
James H. Fitzgerald (MA)
Don Jones (MO)

1987
Dub Bowen (AL)
Al Caruso (NJ)
Sam Gulotta (IL)
Clarence Higgins (AR)
Jeanne B. Layton (NJ)
John W. Nida (WY)
Jerry D. Tresca, Sr. (CA)

1988
Tom Gorman (NJ)
Ted Kuehner (WY)
John Villar (KS)

1989
William A. Axtell (FL)
Frank Rinaudo (LA)
Howard Rohrbacher (FL)
Carmine Salvatore (CT)

1990
Joseph Coglianese (IL)
Samuel "Dudley" Franco (OR)

1991
Vernon "Lefty" Gomez (CA)

1992
Roy Beach (OR)
John Cooper (NJ)
Jack Ryan (OR)

1993
James M. Battiste (AL)
Jack O'Keefe (CA)
Nick E. Welter (IA)

1994
Philip P. Bryan (WV)
Ted B. Church (BC)
Donald H. Diamond (LA)
Bill Frazier (NJ)
Ward Walker (OR)

1995
Donald A. Butler (KY)
Irby Luquette (LA)

1996
Herb Dietrich (NC)
William E. Whitehurst (NC)

1997
Russell E. Diethrick, Jr. (NY)
Donald L. Edwards (OH)
Guy Jackson (MO)
Fred "Wimpy" Quinn (OR)

1998
Warren Arbuthnot (TX)
Edward Corrigan (RI)
Ted Denman (NJ)
Glenn Drake (MO)
Manuel A. Gouveia (NJ)
Charlie Kentfield (IA)
Marvin Lemmon (OR)

1999
Lawrence A. Magers (NY)

2000
Daniel J. Lynch (MA)
Jay R. Kump (NV)
Francis Bland (AR)

2001
John B. McLaughlin (MA)
John J. Oliver (NE)
Joseph E. Shea, Sr. (RI)

2002
Floyd A. Markham (OR)

2003
Harry S. Smith (NJ)

2004
Dick McGuire (ME)
Daniel Perella (CT)
Firmin Simms (LA)